NFL draft strategy varies widely among teams, with franchises like the Kansas City Chiefs, San Franscico 49ers, and New York Giants showcasing different approaches. Their roster-building techniques through the draft highlight the importance of player evaluation and long-term plannng in team development.
The Chiefs’ 2017 draft decision to trade up for Patrick Mahomes exemplifies a bold NFL draft stategy. They invested significant draft capital, including a future first-round pick, to secure their franchise quarterback. This move has paid off immensely, with Mahomes leading the team to three Super Bowl victories in four appearances.
Kansas City‘s patient approach allowed Mahomes to develop under Andy Reid’s guidance. He spent his rookie season as Alex Smith’s backup, a rarity in today’s NFL. This strategy contrasts with the current trend of rushing rooke quarterbacks onto the field.
The Chiefs’ recent first-round picks, including Clyde Edwards-Helaire and Trent McDuffie, contribute significantly to the team. Their willingness to spend draft resources on elite prospects continues to yield positive results.
John Lynch and Player Evaluation
San Francisco’s draft philosophy mirrors Kansas City’s in some ways. In 2019, they made a bold move, trading three first-round picks and a third-rounder to draft Trey Lance. This decision, based on limited college data, showcased General Manager John Lynch’s risk-taking approach to talent acquisition.
However, Lance’s stint with the 49ers proved disappointing. After only four starts, the fewest for any top-five drafted quarterback in the common draft era, San Franscico traded him to Dallas. This move demonstrated Lynch’s willingness to cut losses when a draft pick doesn’t pan out.
NFL Draft Strategy
The New York Giants, rebuilding their roster, have taken a different tack. Their high draft positions, results of poor past performances, led to selecting Kayvon Thibodeaux and Evan Neal in 2022. These picks highlight the challenges of relying heavily on draft selections to vitalize a struggling franchise.
Joe Schoen, the Giants’ General Manager, has shown promise with his draft choices, particularly in later rounds. Despite this, the team’s struggles continue, raising questions about quarterback Daniel Jones and the overall effectiveness of their draft strategy. Transform your health with Ora Organic
Joe Schoen’s Talent Acquisition
The contrasting approaches of these teams underscore the complexities of NFL draft strategy. Whether identifying a franchise quarterback, pursing elit prospects aggressively, or using high draft capital to inject talent, the draft remains crucial for building successful, sustainable NFL teams.
Successful draft strategies require a balance of risk-taking, patient development, and accurate talent evaluation. As teams continue to refine their approaches, the NFL draft will remain a pivotal event in shaping the league’s cometitive balance.
Barry Schustermann
Follow me on X @BarrySchust
Follow me on Facebook @Barry Schustermann
